HomeLedger › Tools › How to choose a homeschool curriculum

How to choose a homeschool curriculum that fits your child

The right homeschool curriculum is the one your child will actually use, that covers your state's required subjects, and that you can teach week after week without dread. Start with your child, then check your state's required subjects, then shortlist two or three options and trial one for two weeks before buying a full year. A curriculum that looks perfect in a catalogue but sits unused on the shelf is the most expensive one you can buy, however little it cost.

Start with your child, not the catalogue

Catalogues sell to parents; children are the ones who have to live with the choice. Before you open one, write down four things about your child. First, how they learn best: by reading, hearing, or doing? A child who learns by doing will stall on a workbook-heavy programme. Second, where they actually are in each subject — a ten-year-old may read at twelve-year-old level and do maths at eight-year-old level. Third, how long they can concentrate — twenty focused minutes beat an hour of staring at a page. Fourth, what they care about: a child obsessed with animals learns more science from a nature-based unit.

Also be honest about yourself: are you happy teaching from a script, or do you want to plan your own lessons — and do you have an hour a day to teach, or three? A working parent needs a curriculum that runs itself for older children; a parent who loves teaching may be bored by an all-in-one box. The curriculum has to fit the teacher as well as the pupil.

Check what your state actually requires

Before you fall in love with a curriculum, check the subjects your state requires you to teach. Most states list subjects — reading, writing, maths, science, history and the like — but prescribe topics, not textbooks. You are free to choose the materials; you are not free to skip a subject your state names. A few states require specific content, such as state history in a particular grade, or an annual test your curriculum should prepare for. Read your state's page in the state directory and the required subjects page first. Anything that leaves a required subject out is not a bargain — you will be buying a second programme to fill the gap.

The four main curriculum approaches — and who each suits

Almost every curriculum falls into one of four approaches.

Many families mix approaches: a textbook for maths, a unit study for history, an online programme for a language. That is normal — no rule says one publisher must supply the whole year. What matters is that every required subject is covered, and that the mix is one you can sustain.

How to compare two curricula side by side

Once you have two or three candidates, compare them on the same six questions — catalogues blur together after the third one.

Trial before you buy: the two-week test

Never buy a full year of anything untried. Most publishers sell a single unit, a single subject, or a short trial — buy the smallest piece and run it for two full weeks. Two weeks is long enough for the novelty to wear off: does your child start without a battle, and do the lessons fit the time you have? At the end of the fortnight, decide on evidence, not money already spent — a cheap curriculum abandoned in October costs more than an expensive one your child finishes in May. Keep the record: the notes go in the portfolio, and the days you taught belong on the attendance tracker.

What to do when a curriculum stops working

Every family hits a wall with a curriculum at some point. Before you throw it out, diagnose the problem. Too hard usually means the placement was wrong — drop back a level in that subject only. Too easy means skip ahead or add harder material alongside it. Too long usually means the lessons are written for a classroom of thirty — cut the busywork and keep the teaching. If, after a fortnight of honest adjustments, you both still dread it, change it. Switching mid-year is allowed, and a switch to something that works beats a full year of something that does not. The cost of not switching is a year of lost learning.

Budget: what a year really costs

Curriculum spending varies enormously, and the cover price is rarely the whole story. Work out the true cost per child per year: core books, workbooks, teacher's guides, and any renewing subscription. Then ask what you already have: your library holds the reading list, and second-hand copies are easy to find. Free resources are real, but free only saves money if it also saves your time. Set the budget before you shop: the most expensive is not the best, and the cheapest is not the worst — the best one is the one your child finishes.

Once you have chosen, the rest of the year is routine: log the days you teach and keep samples of the work. The how-to-start guide walks the whole first year in order, and the portfolio guide shows what to keep as proof. When your child reaches high school, the courses you chose become the transcript — so keep a note of what you used, and why, for every subject.

Common questions

How do I know which homeschool curriculum is best for my child?

The one that matches how your child learns, covers your state's required subjects, and fits your teaching time. Shortlist two or three, then trial one for two weeks — week two tells you more than any review.

Do I need a different curriculum for each subject?

Not necessarily — many families use different publishers per subject: a textbook for maths, a unit study for history, an online course for a language. What matters is that every required subject is covered, at the right level.

Can I change curriculum mid-year?

Yes — switching mid-year is allowed in every state, and a switch to something that works beats a full year of something that does not. Try adjusting the current programme first; if it still fails after a fortnight, change it.

Does my state require a specific curriculum?

No state requires a specific curriculum or textbook — states prescribe topics, not materials. Check your state's page for the subjects it requires, and make sure your choice covers them all.

How much should a homeschool curriculum cost?

No single figure is right: costs range from nearly free, using libraries and free resources, to several hundred per child per year. Work out the true cost per child, set a budget before you shop, and judge a curriculum by whether your child finishes it.